Does Vegetable Gardening Actually Save Money?

000_0486While my primary reason for gardening is love–love of the outdoors, love of physical work, love of plants in their infinite variety–my pleasure in gardening is immeasurably enhanced if I know that my labor is actually productive, if I know that, down the road a few weeks or months, I’m going to be enjoying the fruits of my labor. And that pleasure is even greater if I can put the productivity of my labor in terms of dollar signs.

Now I know as well as anyone that money is not an adequate measure of the benefits of tending a home vegetable garden. After all, those benefits include enjoyment of the outdoors, physical exercise, and food much fresher and more full of taste than anything you can find in a grocery store. And how do you put a price on those things?

Nevertheless, at the end of each growing season, I’m always extremely curious to see how much cash I spent on the garden and how much my harvest would have been worth if purchased at a farmer’s market. That is, how much green stuff did I actually save by all those hours of toil?

In 2012, I spent a  total of $742.64 on my 2000-sq.-ft. vegetable garden. If we subtract from this the amount that I spent on capital investments such as fencing, tools, and pots, which will be usable for many years to come, the figure comes down to $617.14. That includes the cost of all purchased compost, fertilizer ingredients, seeds, and plants. (Though I grow most of my own seedlings, I do purchase seed potatoes, sweet potato slips, and perennials that don’t come true from seed.) The amount for seeds will be less than half of that this year, because my stocks of seeds are so high now that I don’t have to buy nearly as much this spring.

Now, how much was my harvest worth? It’s hard to get a really accurate figure for this, but I do my best to estimate the value of my produce if it were sold at the local farmer’s market. And what I came up with this year was $964. So a profit of from $221 to $347, depending on how much of the capital costs I include.

Honestly, that doesn’t sound like a whole lot of pay for an entire season’s worth of labor. I did a heck of a lot of digging, planting, hoeing, weeding, fertilizing, and watering. I certainly wouldn’t work for those wages anywhere else.

But as I pondered this fact recently, I realized that a lot of the compost, fertilizer, and labor this year went towards crops that were “experimental.” Things that I hadn’t grown before, or at least had never grown well before. And I thought, Well, if I were trying to get the biggest return on my investment and only planted things that were sure to do well, what would I plant, and what would my profit be? In short, I decided to see what would happen if I designed a super-efficient vegetable garden.

I began by figuring out the cost for compost and fertilizer per square foot of garden space. That came to 22.4 cents/sq.ft. for one application of compost and all the applications of fertilizer needed throughout the growing season. I then multiplied this number by the square feet I devoted to a particular crop and divided by the pounds of that crop I harvested. That told me how much that crop cost this year to produce per pound. I could then compare that number to the market value per pound (for organic produce) and determine if that crop was a good profit maker.

My most profitable crops in 2012 were the following:

Pole beans at a cost of $.54/lb and a value of $2.25/lb

Beets at a cost of $.19/lb and a value of $4/lb

Cucumbers at a cost of $.06/lb and a value of $2/lb

Bulbing onions at a cost of $.37/lb and a value of $2/lb

Jupiter green peppers at a cost of $.36/lb and a value of $2.40/lb

Zucchini at a cost of $.15/lb and a value of $2/lb

Pumpkin at a cost of $.30/lb and a value of $1/lb

Hungarian Italian paste tomatoes at a cost of $.41/lb and a value of $3-4/lb

Eva Purple Ball tomatoes at a cost of $.43/lb and a value of $3-4/lb

Leaf lettuce at a cost of $.03/serving and a value of $.50/serving

Now, what if, this year, I planted only these super-profit-makers in my garden? First of all, I wouldn’t need nearly as big a garden. To get enough of these ten types of vegetables to feed my family of four (including a huge amount for canning), I would need to plant only 641 sq. ft. of garden: a little less than one third the size of my current garden. And so, presumably, one third of the work.

000_0569If I planted those 641 sq. ft. with 162 sq. ft. of pole beans, 20 sq. ft. of beets, 9 sq. ft. of cucumbers, 13.5 sq. ft. of lettuce, 38 sq. ft. of bulbing onions, 36 sq. ft. of Jupiter bell peppers, 20 sq. ft. of zucchini, 48 sq. ft. of pumpkins, 144 sq. ft. of paste tomatoes, and 150 sq. ft. of Eva Purple Ball tomatoes, and my yields per square foot were similar to this year’s, then I would reap a harvest of 66 lbs. of pole beans, 7 lbs. of beets, 35.5 lbs. of cucumbers, 120 servings of lettuce, 23 lbs. of bulbing onions, 23 lbs. of bell peppers, 17.5 lbs. of zucchini, 36 lbs. of pumpkin, 78 lbs. of paste tomatoes, and 80 lbs. of Eva Purple Ball tomatoes. And the total cost of compost and fertilizer for that garden? $138.33. When the value of the harvest would be somewhere in the vicinity of $940.

That is, I could get almost the same money value of food out of this super-efficient garden as with my actual 2012 garden. But I’d use only one third of the space and one third of the labor and invest less than one third of the cash.

So, am I going to plant the super-efficient garden this year?

Of course not. Or rather, I’m going to plant the super-efficient garden, but I’m also going to plant another 1000 sq. ft. of other crops that may not produce such a big financial return but that I want to learn how to grow. Or that I want to have the convenience of having always at the ready in my own garden.

Because that’s a benefit to a home vegetable garden that we haven’t mentioned yet: the fact that all of this food is waiting outside your doorstep whenever you decide to harvest it. You don’t have to get in your car and go to the market or grocery store. You don’t have to decide ahead of time what you’re going to want to cook this week, and then feel bad when half of your produce rots unused in the crisper drawer. A lot of the food in a home vegetable garden can stay on the plants until it’s time to eat it, which means less room taken up in the fridge, more variety available when each new mealtime arrives, and hopefully less waste.

Large Red Tomato
Large Red Tomato

Another reason that I wouldn’t plant only the super-efficient vegetable garden is that some of the best foods in my garden grow on plants that are not terribly productive and even a little finicky. For instance, the Large Red tomato. This heirloom tomato is tastier than any other I’ve ever eaten, from the store or from a garden. Last year it yielded less than 1 lb. per 9 sq. ft. (the previous year it did much better), but if I hadn’t had any Large Reds, it wouldn’t even have felt like summer. The taste of the Large Red is reason enough in itself to garden. And so even though this past year it cost me $1.93/lb. to produce, I’m planting them again this year, and in even greater quantity.

The same goes for watermelon. Last year was a bad year for my watermelon plants. I planted two hills, totaling 48 sq. ft., and I only harvested one watermelon, which weighed in at 9 lbs. But again, it wouldn’t have felt like summer without that taste. That sweetness is simply not available at the store.

And so, yes, it is possible to save a great deal of money by tending a home vegetable garden. And for people who have a very tight budget, I can recommend a few crops that would be very profitable investments. But even people on very tight budgets should consider splurging on a few Large Reds. Because, really, even at $1.93/lb., they’re a steal. And, eating them, you’ll feel like you’re living in the lap of luxury.


12 Comments Add yours

  1. I love this post! It appeals to both the gardener and the business coach in me! It’s driving me mental right now that I can’t just walk out to the garden and get whatever I need for dinner. Now I want a green house! I think there are definitely intangible benefits, regardless of the bottom line.

    1. Sharon says:

      Oh, yes, the winter dreams of a greenhouse…

  2. Amy J Burton says:

    I love the fact that you’ve done the maths. I’m looking forward to being able to work out which crops work best and I’m looking forward to your new growing season 🙂

    1. Sharon says:

      I’m looking forward to the new growing season, too! I just put my first onion seeds in their flat yesterday! So exciting…

  3. Carolyn says:

    Love to see the new post! Thanks for doing the math. I think it should be less expensive this year for compost, etc. You inspire me!

    1. Sharon says:

      Hi, Carolyn! Yes, I do hope that I’ll be saving a lot on compost this year by using more of my own and finding a less expensive source than the hardware store.

  4. garden.poet says:

    Really interesting. I’ve always wondered how a bigger operation such as yours would look in the numbers!

    1. Sharon says:

      This year I might keep closer track of the amount of time I spend working in the garden. But then again, that might take some of the enjoyment out of it…

  5. Dan will LOVE this post- I can’t wait to show him the numbers 🙂
    Plus, If you consider the cost of education these days- it’s a steal!

    1. Sharon says:

      Haha–you’re absolutely right! And where can you learn more than in a garden? Really.

  6. Gerlinde says:

    I just came across your detailed post just now as our gardening season is being wrapped up.. I am a volunteer at a community garden and on 2180 sq ft we grew 1260 pounds of vegetables and 66 pounds of berries. The standard used to determine the value of organically grown vegetables for Canadian Foodbanks is $ 2.50 per pound. So for the vegetables that is $3165.00 because an across the board valuation is used. Our final costs are not in but I figure we did make a profit because all the volunteers donae their time and a lot of us started the seedlings at home. We also got seed donations. We bought compost that was to cover 900 sq ft but we spread it over the whole garden, since we also have composters that produce our own compost. The cost was $210. We are waiting for the cost of water. Other than that we used no fertilizer and only organic pest control at minimal cost. Beer for slugs and snails, fishy oil in tuna cans for earwigs,crushed eggshells for some insects and slugs blood meal, fox urine and nets for the strawberries and a waspinator for the raspberries. I guess that added another $ 60. to $100 to the cost.
    The main benefit however, cannot be measured in dollars. We provided fresh from the garden, healthy, pesticide free veggies to foodbank recipients who normally eat a very poor diet because they are poor. Garden work for the volunteers provided companionship, good excercise and a sense of wellbeing. We cannot put a value on this.


    1. Sounds like you had a very successful year in the community garden! Thanks for sharing your figures. Of course, I agree with you that the greatest benefits aren’t quantifiable. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s